Understanding my “Why?”

So, about that panic attack the other day….

Yes, I’d just had a ton of success, and yes, maybe I’m afraid of it…but something else may have triggered it too.

I had just gotten finished with a good counseling session, where I wondered aloud, “Why did I get involved with the Quiverful/Patriarchy movement, after working so hard to get out of my crazy Narcissistic/Borderline parents’ control?”

My counselor replied, “Maybe, since your mother was so abusive, you were trying to swing in the complete opposite direction, so you could land somewhere in the middle.”  Maybe.  That kind of made sense.

So, I got home, and went to the BPDfamily.com boards, where I spent so much of my time healing from my parents’ mind-control.  I read through about four years of old posts of mine, where I described what it was like to grow up with TWO parents who were crazy mentally ill.  [My mother has Borderline Personality Disorder, and my dad is a certifiable Narcissist.]

At first, I was smiling.  I couldn’t help it–I was feeling proud.  I thought, “I can’t believe I actually survived all this trauma, and still wanted to be the best mother I could be.”  I mean, the stereotype is that women who are abused go on to abuse their own kids.  I didn’t.  I was so thankful.

However, guess what I saw over and over again, while going over my own freaking writings?  My parents used almost exactly the same twisting of language, the same emotional methods of control, and even the same worship of “family,” that the QF/P movement uses.  They just phrased it mostly in secular terms.

Even worse, as a kid of a BPD/NPD, I used the SAME coping techniques in QF/P that I used with them: never speak badly of them, smile all the time, obey authority, keep everything perfect, be a model daughter[mother/wife] and adapt to exactly what they want you to be.

It was, as my husband’s grandfather used to say, “Out of the frying pan, into the skillet.”

I’m not the first person to make this connection.  The writers of the blog, Overcoming Botkin Syndrome , about recovering from one of the most extreme examples of Christian Patriarchy, also saw the common traits in parents with Personality Disorders, and the leaders of the QF/P movement.


There’s so much more to process here, so much more information to mine, and so many examples that I want to give….but the point is that I lept from one prison into another, most likely because it was familiar.  Maybe, in a sick twisted way, even comforting.  It gave me the illusion of control over my life.

I wonder now about the chicken and the egg–which came first in the Patriarchy movement: The Personality Disorder, or the Twisted Scripture?  With the Doug Phillips scandal, I can’t help but wonder, did these assholes actually have Narcissistic Personality Disorder, and twist scripture in a way to get all the narcissistic supply they wanted?

Gosh, I feel like I have so much writing to do, so many definitions to explain, and so much I want to share, in order to make all of these connections plain to readers who didn’t go through this.  But at least now, I understand the why of what I went through.  I feel so much more comfortable leaving the Patriarchy’s teachings behind, realizing that the leaders used the same method of Bible exegesis that my parents did: “Whatever I Want it to Mean.”


One thought on “Understanding my “Why?”

  1. Yes, indeed, out of the fying pan and into the fire. I can SO relate! What an empowering feeling it is to break free from spiritual and emotional manipulation. High five, sister!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s